Home › Game Previews › NHL › September 2026 › New York Islanders at Toronto Maple Leafs
NHL · September 30, 2026

New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs Final — September 30, 2026

Wednesday, September 30 · 7:47 PM ET
Starting goalies
Last season
54
Starts
25
.906
Sv%
.893
.896
HDSv%
.871
+27.3
GSAx
−5.3
OffenseFull 2025-26 regular season (last season)
24th2.84
GF/G
3.0916th
29th5.93
PP GF/60
7.0619th
Defense
7th2.94
GA/G
3.6531st
11th7.12
PK GA/60
6.486th
Team
19th55.5%
Pts%
47.6%28th
24th47.9%
xGF%
45.5%29th
18th49.0%
CF%
44.8%32nd
26th45.5%
HDCF%
45.2%28th
5-on-5
16th2.53
xGF/60
2.2928th
28th2.74
xGA/60
2.7427th
28th8.3%
Sh%
10.3%8th
11th91.0%
Sv%
90.0%22nd
14th116.0
CF/60 (both)
117.29th
15th51.0%
xGF% (L20)
40.5%31st
Special teams
28th8.59
PP xG/60
8.9419th
30th69.8
PP FF/60
73.525th
12th4.8
PP min/G
4.031st
32nd11.46
PK xGA/60
10.6431st
5th4.2
PK min/G
4.718th
Top third of the leagueMiddle thirdBottom thirdBar = league rank (full = 1st)
Injuries & restkey injuries · rest and travel
Rest & travel
—
Days of rest
Back-to-back0 days off
Key injuries
Mathew Barzal CInjured Reserve
Players out or limited
Cade Webber DInjured ReserveDakota Joshua CInjured ReserveElvis Merzlikins GInjured ReserveMax Domi CInjured ReserveWilliam Villeneuve DInjured Reserve
About these numbers

Goalie status from the G&W goalie tracker (Confirmed, Expected, Likely or Not confirmed); teams confirm starters close to puck drop. Season lines come from the NHL Lab goalie tables. GSAx = goals saved above expected (Gridiron & Wine expected goals). HD Sv% = save rate on high-danger shots.

Full 2025-26 regular season (last season), captured before puck drop. League rank in small type (32 teams); the gold side ranks higher. Bars show rank, longest = 1st. Source: Gridiron & Wine public Analytics tables.

2025-26 regular season, public NHL Lab tables; ranks out of 32 teams. Expected goals are Gridiron & Wine's own expected-goals numbers.

2025-26 regular season. Rates are per 60 minutes of power-play or penalty-kill time.

Regular-season results this season, oldest to newest (OTL = overtime or shootout loss). Records are season to date, with home and road splits. Over–under uses the consensus closing total.

Distance is a straight-line estimate from the arena of each team's previous game, not the team's actual itinerary; time-zone change is at game time. Days of rest are full days off since each team's previous game this season (0 = back-to-back); preseason games do not count. Schedule facts only: no fatigue adjustment is applied.

Injury report as of September 30, 10:10 a.m. ET (status and injury type only).

The pre-game matchup

The Islanders visited the Maple Leafs on Wednesday, September 30 at 7:47 PM ET.

Last season (2025-26), the Islanders scored 2.84 goals per game (24th of 32) and allowed 2.94 (7th). The Maple Leafs scored 3.09 goals per game (16th of 32) and allowed 3.65 (31st). The Islanders earned 55.5% of available standings points (19th) and the Maple Leafs 47.6% (28th).

Expected-goals share (5-on-5), the share of 5-on-5 expected goals created: Islanders 47.9% (24th), Maple Leafs 45.5% (29th). Shot-attempt share (5-on-5), the share of all 5-on-5 shot attempts: Islanders 49.0% (18th), Maple Leafs 44.8% (32nd). High-danger chance share, the share of 5-on-5 high-danger chances: Islanders 45.5% (26th), Maple Leafs 45.2% (28th). These are last season's full-season numbers because the new season's sample is still small; rosters change over the offseason.

The total closed at 5.5, down from 6.5 at the open. After removing the vig, the closing moneyline (Islanders +118, Maple Leafs -140) prices the Islanders at 44% and the Maple Leafs at 56%.

Written from the numbers available before puck drop.

Result

Final score and result vs the closing line

New York Islanders 1, Toronto Maple Leafs 2

Toronto Maple Leafs won by 1.

  • Against the closing spread (Toronto Maple Leafs -1.5): New York Islanders covered.
  • Combined score 3 vs the closing total of 5.5: Under.
  • Toronto Maple Leafs closed at -140 on the moneyline (a 56% no-vig market-implied chance).

Actual result

Final
New York Islanders 1
Toronto Maple Leafs 2
Decided
In regulation
Toronto Maple Leafs won
Lead changes
0

Before the game: market and G&W

44%Market at the close56%
New York IslandersToronto Maple Leafs
49%Market at the open51%

From open to close the market moved 5 points toward Toronto Maple Leafs.

The G&W pregame win probability for this game is available to Analytics members. See plans

Market numbers are the consensus moneyline with the bookmaker margin removed.

Win probability

Each team's chance of winning through the game, starting from the market's closing price (New York Islanders 44%, Toronto Maple Leafs 56%) and moving with every goal, penalty and the clock until the final.

100%75%50%75%100%1st2nd3rdOTMarket start11st 7:14: Toronto Maple Leafs 56% to 71%21st 11:55: Toronto Maple Leafs 71% to 85%33rd 14:09: New York Islanders 1% to 9%■ Maple Leafs■ Islanders
 

Biggest swings

  1. 1st 7:14 — Toronto Maple Leafs goal (0-1)Toronto Maple Leafs 56% → 71% (+15 pts)
  2. 1st 11:55 — Toronto Maple Leafs goal (0-2)Toronto Maple Leafs 71% → 85% (+13 pts)
  3. 3rd 14:09 — New York Islanders goal (1-2)New York Islanders 1% → 9% (+8 pts)
Analytics members also see this chart starting from the G&W pregame win probability. See plans

Chance Quality Result

48%NYI
Share of G&W replays won
52%TOR
2.2
Expected goals
2.4
1
Final score
2

Based on the quality of chances each team created, Toronto Maple Leafs won 52% of G&W replays (New York Islanders 48%). The chances each team created were close to even.

The Chance Quality Result describes the chances each team created. It is not the official result and never changes it or any record. Expected goals count regulation chances with both goalies in net; empty-net goals are not included. Season xG tables count every game state, empty nets included, so their totals differ.

Game DNA

The Chance Quality Result above had the chances close to even. Here is where each side gained and lost.

IslandersGoalsMaple Leafs
1.45-on-5 chancesexpected goals
1.6
0.6Power-play chancesexpected goals
0.8
0.2Other situations4-on-4, 3-on-3, short-handed
0.0
2.2Chance Quality Result chancesthe three rows above, as in the result
2.4
0.4Overtime and pulled-goalie chancesnot part of the Chance Quality Result
0.2
0.1Second chancesrebounds and flurries, part of the above
0.5
-1.6Finishinggoals vs expected on own shots
-0.6
+0.6Goaltendingsaves vs expected · Ilya Sorokin 24/26 · Anthony Stolarz 26/27
+1.6
Bar left: Islanders gainedBar right: Maple Leafs gained

How the margin was built, from Toronto Maple Leafs's side:

Chances +0.0Finishing & goaltending +1.0Toronto Maple Leafs by 1

The first three rows add up to the Chance Quality Result's expected goals. Overtime chances and chances with a goalie pulled are listed on their own, and empty-net goals are not in expected goals. A team's finishing and the other team's goaltending are the same goals seen from each end.

The official play, graded

The official play on this game, at the price it was sent, graded against the final score.

Jessica's HandicapNew York Islanders ML +1201uLOSS -1u

Full track record.

Line review

Toronto Maple Leafs closed as the market favourite at 56% and won.

The line moved toward Toronto Maple Leafs before puck drop, and they won.

How the G&W pregame number compared with the close, and whether the line moved toward it, is available to Analytics members. See plans

Market

Closing line and line movement

Puck lineno move
OpenMaple Leafs -1.5 (+200)
Islanders +1.5 (-265)
CloseMaple Leafs -1.5 (+180)
Islanders +1.5 (-225)
Totaldown 1
Open6.5 (o +106 / u -135)
Close5.5 (o -136 / u +114)
Moneyline
OpenIslanders -105 49%
Maple Leafs -118 51%
CloseIslanders +118 44%
Maple Leafs -140 56%

Consensus of US sportsbooks. Open = first line after both teams' previous games; Close = consensus at puck drop. Percentages are the moneyline's no-vig market-implied chances.

Matchup

Head-to-head

The teams have met 20 times since 2018-19: the Islanders won 12 and the Maple Leafs 8.

DateScoreLineTotal
Apr 9, 2026Maple Leafs 3, Islanders 5
Islanders won


Mar 17, 2026Islanders 3, Maple Leafs 1
Islanders won
Islanders -160
favorite won
6
under
Jan 3, 2026Maple Leafs 3, Islanders 4 OT
Islanders won
Maple Leafs -115
underdog won
5.5
over
Jan 2, 2025Maple Leafs 2, Islanders 1
Maple Leafs won
Maple Leafs -113
favorite won
6
under
Dec 31, 2024Islanders 1, Maple Leafs 3
Maple Leafs won
Maple Leafs -134
favorite won
6
under

Regular-season meetings since 2018-19, most recent first. Line = consensus closing moneyline favorite and total where line history is available.

Teams

New York Islanders

Toronto Maple Leafs

Gridiron & Wine graded a pick on this game: see the archived pick.

Follow the market every day

See every game's current line on the odds board, or check our fully tracked results.

Odds boardTracked results