Home › Game Previews › NFL › September 2026 › Indianapolis Colts at Kansas City Chiefs
NFL · Week 2 · September 20, 2026

Indianapolis Colts vs Kansas City Chiefs Final — September 20, 2026

Indianapolis Colts logo
0-1
30
Quarterback Daniel Jones Status pending
FINAL
Kansas City Chiefs logo
1-0
33
Quarterback Patrick Mahomes Status pending
Sunday, September 20 · 8:20 PM ETGEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium · outdoorsWeek 2
INDStarting quarterbacksexpected startersKC
29th−0.441
EPA/dropback
+0.02617th
26th38.2%
Success %
42.4%19th
25th−5.1
CPOE
−11.932nd
15th5.9%
Sack %
6.1%16th
1–1
TD–INT
2–1
34
Dropbacks
33
INDOffense2026 regular season to dateKC
27th−0.241
EPA/play
+0.16410th
22nd41.5%
Success %
42.2%18th
30th−0.441
EPA/dropback
+0.02617th
5th+0.116
EPA/rush
+0.3111st
18th23.0
PPG
31.08th
INDDefenseKC
29th+0.321
EPA/play allowed
−0.3441st
27th50.0%
Success % allowed
37.0%5th
28th+0.459
EPA/dropback allowed
−0.4432nd
30th+0.192
EPA/rush allowed
−0.09214th
31st41.0
Opp PPG
10.02nd
INDRecent formKC
Lvs BAL 23-41
Resultsoldest to newest
Wvs DEN 31-10
0-1
Record
1-0
0-1
ATS
1-0
1-0
Over–under
0-1
Top third of the leagueMiddle thirdBottom thirdBar = league rank (full = 1st)
Injuries & restkey injuries · rest and travel
INDRest & travelKC
7 days
Days of rest
6 days
447 mi719 km
Travel to the game
Home
−1 hclock change vs home
Time-zone change
Home
VenueGEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium
Outdoors
INDKey injuriesKC
None listed
Players out or limited
Chamarri Conner SOutJosh Simmons TOutChris Jones DTQuestionable
About these numbers

Quarterback = expected starter for this game. Season to date; ranks among 32 qualified quarterbacks (at least 14 dropbacks per team game); a starter below that minimum is placed among them. Success rate = share of dropbacks and designed runs that gain expected points.

2026 regular season to date, captured before kickoff. League rank in small type (32 teams); the gold side ranks higher. Bars show rank, longest = 1st. Source: play-by-play via the public NFL Lab tables (raw EPA, not opponent-adjusted).

Last five results this season, oldest to newest. Records are season to date, with home and road splits. Against-the-spread (ATS) and over–under records use the consensus closing line.

Distance is straight-line from each team's home stadium; time-zone change is at kickoff. Rest counts days since each team's previous game.

No key players listed out, doubtful or questionable.

Starters (and the primary passer), plus regular contributors playing at least 40% of team snaps, on the game's official injury report captured before kickoff.

The pre-game matchup

The Colts (0-1) visited the Chiefs (1-0) at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium on Sunday, September 20 at 8:20 PM ET in Week 2.

The Colts have the 27th-ranked offense by EPA per play (expected points added per snap) and the 29th-ranked defense. Meanwhile, the Chiefs have the 10th-ranked offense and the 1st-ranked defense. When the Colts have the ball, a 27th-ranked offense (−0.241 EPA per play) meets a 1st-ranked defense (−0.344 allowed); when the Chiefs have it, a 10th-ranked offense (+0.164) meets a 29th-ranked defense (+0.321 allowed).

By success rate (the share of plays that gain expected points), the Colts offense is at 41.5% (22nd) and the Chiefs offense at 42.2% (18th). Through the air, the Colts average −0.441 EPA per dropback (30th) against a Chiefs pass defense ranked 2nd; the Chiefs average +0.026 (17th) against a Colts pass defense ranked 28th. The Colts score 23.0 points per game (18th) and allow 41.0 (31st); the Chiefs score 31.0 (8th) and allow 10.0 (2nd).

Patrick Mahomes has a 42.4% success rate (19th of 32 qualified quarterbacks) compared to Daniel Jones' 38.2% (26th). Per dropback, Mahomes is at +0.026 EPA to Jones' −0.441, with 2 touchdown passes and 1 interception to Jones' 1 and 1.

The Colts are 0-1 and 0-1 against the spread; their last game was a 41-23 loss to the Ravens. The Chiefs are 1-0 and 1-0 against the spread; their last game was a 31-10 win over the Broncos.

The Chiefs closed as 6-point favorites at home against the Colts. The spread opened at Chiefs -6.5. The total closed at 45.5, down from 47.5 at the open. After removing the vig, the closing moneyline (Colts +228, Chiefs -280) prices the Colts at 29% and the Chiefs at 71%.

Written from the numbers available before kickoff.

Result

Final score and result vs the closing line

Indianapolis Colts 30, Kansas City Chiefs 33

Kansas City Chiefs won by 3.

  • Against the closing spread (Kansas City Chiefs -6): Indianapolis Colts covered.
  • Combined score 63 vs the closing total of 45.5: Over.
  • Kansas City Chiefs closed at -280 on the moneyline (a 71% no-vig market-implied chance).

Before the game: market and G&W

29%Market at the close71%
Indianapolis ColtsKansas City Chiefs
26%Market at the open74%

From open to close the market moved 3 points toward Indianapolis Colts.

The G&W pregame win probability for this game is available to Analytics members. See plans

Market numbers are the consensus moneyline with the bookmaker margin removed.

Win probability

Each team's chance of winning through the game, starting from the market's closing price (Indianapolis Colts 29%, Kansas City Chiefs 71%) and moving with every snap until the final.

100%75%50%75%100%Q1Q2Q3Q4OTMarket start1Q3 10:38: Kansas City Chiefs 57% to 74%2Q4 0:40: Kansas City Chiefs 43% to 57%3OT 8:38: Kansas City Chiefs 52% to 81%4OT 5:04: Indianapolis Colts 36% to 67%5OT 0:01: Kansas City Chiefs 74% to 100%■ Chiefs■ Colts
 

Biggest swings

  1. Q3 10:38 — Kansas City Chiefs ball, 3rd & 11 at IND 46(Shotgun) 15-P.Mahomes pass deep right to 2-T.Thornton to IND 1 for 45 yards (57-J.Carlies).Kansas City Chiefs 57% → 74% (+17 pts) · Drive 12 in Drive X-Ray
  2. Q4 0:40 — Indianapolis Colts ball, 3rd & 4 at IND 49(Shotgun) 17-D.Jones pass incomplete short right [91-F.Anudike-Uzomah].Kansas City Chiefs 43% → 57% (+14 pts) · Drive 17 in Drive X-Ray
  3. OT 8:38 — Kansas City Chiefs ball, 3rd & 12 at KC 30(Shotgun) 15-P.Mahomes pass deep right to 2-T.Thornton to IND 40 for 30 yards (30-H.Wohler).Kansas City Chiefs 52% → 81% (+29 pts) · Drive 19 in Drive X-Ray
  4. OT 5:04 — Indianapolis Colts ball, 1st & 10 at IND 3517-D.Jones pass deep middle to 13-L.Treadwell to KC 15 for 50 yards (20-N.Williams). FUMBLES (20-N.Williams), RECOVERED by KC-38-L.Sneed at KC 15. The Replay Official reviewed the runner was not down by contact ruIndianapolis Colts 36% → 67% (+31 pts) · Drive 20 in Drive X-Ray
  5. OT 0:01 — Kansas City Chiefs ball, 2nd & 8 at IND 227-H.Butker 40 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-41-J.Winchester, Holder-14-M.Araiza.Kansas City Chiefs 74% → 100% (+26 pts) · Drive 21 in Drive X-Ray

Kansas City Chiefs won after falling as low as 33% (OT 4:50).

Analytics members also see this chart starting from the G&W pregame win probability. See plans

Chance Quality Result

12%IND
Chance to win, from chances created
88%KC
23.4
Expected points
32.4
30
Final score
33

Based on the quality of each team's plays, Kansas City Chiefs would win 88% of the time (Indianapolis Colts 12%). The result went to the side that created the better chances.

The Chance Quality Result describes the chances each team created. It is not the official result and never changes it or any record.

Game DNA

The Chance Quality Result above favoured Kansas City Chiefs. Here is where that came from.

ColtsPoints addedChiefs
-1.9Passingdropbacks
-7.7
+1.0Rushingdesigned runs
+2.8
+11.6Explosive plays7 plays · 13 plays
+21.4
-4.7Turnovers1 giveaways · 0 giveaways
+0.0
+4.5Special teamskicks, punts and returns
+1.6
+2.6Penalties5 for 30 yds · 8 for 86 yds
-2.9
+3.7Red zoneTDs on trips: 2 of 3 · 3 of 5
+1.3
+16.9All plays
+16.6
Bar left: Colts gainedBar right: Chiefs gained

The biggest single gap: explosive plays, worth about 9.8 points to Kansas City Chiefs. The final margin was 3.

Points added: what each team's plays added to its expected points, credited to the team with the ball. Each play counts once.

The official play, graded

The official play on this game, at the price it was sent, graded against the final score.

Jessica's HandicapIndianapolis Colts +6.5 -1152uWIN +2u
Official playUnder 48.5 -1082uLOSS -2.16u

Full track record.

Line review

Kansas City Chiefs closed as the market favourite at 71% and won.

The line moved toward Indianapolis Colts before kickoff, and they lost.

How the G&W pregame number compared with the close, and whether the line moved toward it, is available to Analytics members. See plans

Drive X-Ray

Every possession of this game, drive by drive. Hover or tap a drive for the plays.

Every other game: Drive X-Ray.

Market

Closing line and line movement

Spreadmoved 0.5
OpenChiefs -6.5 (-117)
Colts +6.5 (-105)
CloseChiefs -6 (-108)
Colts +6 (-112)
Totaldown 2
Open47.5 (o -110 / u -110)
Close45.5 (o -110 / u -109)
Moneyline
OpenColts +260 26%
Chiefs -337 74%
CloseColts +228 29%
Chiefs -280 71%

Consensus of US sportsbooks. Open = first line after both teams' previous games; Close = consensus at kickoff. Percentages are the moneyline's no-vig market-implied chances.

Matchup

Players to watch

Keenan Allen has 32 receiving yards for the Colts (54th of 82 qualified wide receivers) with a target share of 20.7%. Jonathan Taylor has 98 rushing yards on 19 carries (8th of 47 qualified running backs). Xavier Worthy has 18 receiving yards for the Chiefs (71st of 82 qualified wide receivers) with a target share of 24.0%. Kenneth Walker III has 173 rushing yards on 23 carries (1st of 47 qualified running backs).

Indianapolis Colts logo
Colts
RB · Jonathan Taylor
  • Carries19
  • Rush yards988th
  • Yards per carry5.212th
  • EPA per rush+0.11610th
  • Rush success rate47.4%15th
WR · Keenan Allen
  • Targets / catches6 / 6
  • Receiving yards3254th
  • Target share20.7%37th
  • Yards per target5.360th
  • EPA per target−0.00159th
TE · Tyler Warren
  • Targets / catches5 / 3
  • Receiving yards1330th
  • Target share17.2%17th
  • Yards per target2.632nd
  • EPA per target−0.11127th
Kansas City Chiefs logo
Chiefs
RB · Kenneth Walker III
  • Carries23
  • Rush yards1731st
  • Yards per carry7.52nd
  • EPA per rush+0.4393rd
  • Rush success rate47.8%13th
WR · Xavier Worthy
  • Targets / catches6 / 3
  • Receiving yards1871st
  • Target share24.0%22nd
  • Yards per target3.073rd
  • EPA per target−1.40877th
TE · Travis Kelce
  • Targets / catches5 / 3
  • Receiving yards716th
  • Target share20.0%11th
  • Yards per target14.24th
  • EPA per target+0.9946th

Among players not listed out or doubtful on this game’s captured injury report, the featured back has the most carries and receivers the most targets over each team's last four games. This is a usage comparison, not a confirmed starting lineup. Stats are season to date; ranks among qualified players at the position (6.25 carries, 3 targets for wide receivers or 2.5 for tight ends per team game).

Success by situation

Early-down success rate45.2% / 34.8%league 44.5%
3rd-down conversion rate30.0% / 56.2%league 40.6%
Red-zone TD rate100.0% / 60.0%league 66.7%
SituationColtsChiefs
Early-down success rateColts offense vs Chiefs defense45.2%15th39.4%7th
Early-down success rateChiefs offense vs Colts defense52.9%28th34.8%30th
Early-down EPA per playColts offense vs Chiefs defense−0.20729th−0.07813th
Early-down EPA per playChiefs offense vs Colts defense+0.30630th−0.07821st
3rd-down conversion rateColts offense vs Chiefs defense30.0%22nd16.7%2nd
3rd-down conversion rateChiefs offense vs Colts defense37.5%16th56.2%7th
3rd-down EPA per playColts offense vs Chiefs defense−0.07316th−0.8752nd
3rd-down EPA per playChiefs offense vs Colts defense+0.84430th+0.2969th
Red-zone TD rateColts offense vs Chiefs defense100.0%1st50.0%8th
Red-zone TD rateChiefs offense vs Colts defense75.0%18th60.0%19th
Red-zone success rateColts offense vs Chiefs defense75.0%3rd50.0%19th
Red-zone success rateChiefs offense vs Colts defense54.5%24th40.0%20th

On early downs the Colts succeed on 45.2% of plays (15th) against a Chiefs defense that allows 39.4% (7th); on 3rd down they convert 30.0% (22nd) against a defense allowing 16.7% (2nd). On early downs the Chiefs succeed on 34.8% of plays (30th) against a Colts defense that allows 52.9% (28th); on 3rd down they convert 56.2% (7th) against a defense allowing 37.5% (16th). The Colts score touchdowns on 100.0% of red-zone trips (1st). The Chiefs score touchdowns on 60.0% of red-zone trips (19th).

Each row pairs one offense with the defense it faces; for a defense the rank is how stingy it is (1st = allows the least). Ranks out of 32 teams, season to date before kickoff.

Coaching and tendencies

Colts head coachShane Steichen
Chiefs head coachAndy Reid
StaffColtsChiefs
Head coachShane SteichenAndy Reid
Offensive coordinatorJim Bob CooterEric Bieniemy
Defensive coordinatorLou AnarumoSteve Spagnuolo
Pass rate over expected−4.5% / 0.1%league −2.6%
Seconds per snap33.4 / 29.7league 32.7
Early-down dropback rate61.9% / 47.8%league 54.6%
Offense tendenciesColtsChiefs
Pass rate over expecteddropbacks above what down, distance and score suggest · league −2.6%−4.5%21st-highest0.1%11th-highest
Dropback rateshare of plays that are dropbacks · league 59.9%64.2%12th-highest51.6%26th-highest
Early-down dropback rate1st and 2nd down · league 54.6%61.9%10th-highest47.8%24th-highest
Shotgun rateshare of snaps · league 58.6%64.2%13th-highest59.4%16th-highest
No-huddle rateshare of snaps · league 6.8%13.2%5th-highest0.0%30th-highest
Seconds per snapneutral situations; lower is faster · league 32.733.416th-slowest29.726th-slowest
Explosive passes (15+ yards)share of pass plays · league 14.9%6.2%30th12.9%19th
Explosive passes (20+ yards)share of pass plays · league 8.0%6.2%19th6.5%18th
Explosive runs (10+ yards)share of designed runs · league 10.6%26.3%1st12.9%7th
Sack ratesacks per dropback · league 6.3%5.9%14th6.1%15th
Turnovers per playinterceptions and lost fumbles · league 2.20%3.77%26th1.56%12th
Plays per gameoffensive snaps · league 59.653.021st-most64.010th-most
4th-and-short go ratewent for it on 4th-and-2 or shorter beyond their own 30 · league 45.7%—2 of 2
DefenseColtsChiefs
Sack rate generatedleague 6.3%6.9%15th12.1%4th
Explosive passes (15+ yards) allowedleague 14.9%33.3%31st3.4%2nd
Explosive passes (20+ yards) allowedleague 8.0%11.1%21st0.0%1st
Explosive runs (10+ yards) allowedleague 10.6%12.9%25th8.3%13th
Takeaways per playleague 2.20%1.67%17th4.35%3rd
QB hits generatedper dropback · league 15.8%10.3%25th21.2%8th
QB hits allowedper dropback · league 15.8%26.5%29th15.2%16th

The Colts run more often than down, distance and score would suggest (−4.5% pass rate over expected, 21st-highest), while the Chiefs sit at 0.1% (11th-highest). In neutral situations the Colts take 33.4 seconds between snaps and the Chiefs 29.7, so the Chiefs play faster.

Season to date before kickoff, from play-by-play (regular season). Ranks out of 32 teams; for style stats with no better or worse, rank 1 = highest.

EPA rank trend

Colts offense
after wk 127th
Colts defense
after wk 129th
Chiefs offense
after wk 110th
Chiefs defense
after wk 11st

Season-to-date EPA per play rank after each week (offense: 1st = most efficient; defense: 1st = allows the least).

Head-to-head

The teams have met 5 times since 2015: the Colts won 2 and the Chiefs 3. In the most recent meeting (November 23, 2025), the Chiefs won 23-20; the Colts averaged −0.004 EPA per play; the Chiefs averaged +0.014 EPA per play.

DateScoreSpreadTotalEPA/play
Nov 23, 2025Colts 20, Chiefs 23
Chiefs won
Chiefs -3.5
Colts covered
50.5
under
Colts −0.004 · Chiefs +0.014
Sep 25, 2022Chiefs 17, Colts 20
Colts won
Chiefs -4.5
Colts covered
51
under
Colts −0.161 · Chiefs +0.035
Oct 6, 2019Colts 19, Chiefs 13
Colts won
Chiefs -10.5
Colts covered
55.5
under
Colts +0.010 · Chiefs −0.086
Jan 12, 2019 playoffsColts 13, Chiefs 31
Chiefs won
Chiefs -4
Chiefs covered
54.5
under
Colts −0.238 · Chiefs +0.072
Oct 30, 2016Chiefs 30, Colts 14
Chiefs won
Chiefs -3
Chiefs covered
50.5
under
Colts −0.193 · Chiefs +0.133

The last five meetings since 2015, most recent first. Spread and total are the closing lines.

Teams

Indianapolis Colts

Kansas City Chiefs

Gridiron & Wine graded a pick on this game: see the archived pick.

More NFL games on September 20, 2026

All NFL games in September 2026

Follow the market every day

See every game's current line on the odds board, or check our fully tracked results.

Odds boardTracked results